Oh boy, what a letdown! Picture this: You're all hyped for a Christmas flick that's supposed to break the mold in a sea of sugary, predictable holiday fluff—like those Netflix staples such as "A Very Jonas Christmas Movie," "A Christmas Prince," or "Holidate." This one promised real star power with Michelle Pfeiffer, Felicity Jones, and Chloë Grace Moretz, plus direction from Michael Showalter, the guy behind the Oscar-nominated "The Eyes of Tammy Faye." And get this—it kicks off with a bold, cheeky jab at the whole Christmas movie trope, delivering a sharp feminist critique of classics like "Planes, Trains and Automobiles." In a standout opening scene, Pfeiffer plays Claire Clauster, a fed-up Texan mom who quips, "Steve Martin is hailed as a hero just for struggling to get home over a few days? Meanwhile, his wife barely gets 89 seconds on screen!" It's a moment that feels fresh and empowering, right? But here's where it gets controversial... does this kind of meta-take on holiday films really subvert the genre, or does it just highlight how tired these tropes have become? Think about it—some might argue it's a clever way to poke fun at outdated narratives, while others could see it as preachy or unnecessary.
Sadly, the film fizzles out from there, slipping into a familiar "dysfunctional family holiday" storyline that's eerily similar to movies like "The Family Stone" or "Christmas with the Kranks," clumsily mashed up with echoes of "Home Alone." For beginners who might not know, "Home Alone" is that iconic 1990s comedy where a kid defends his house from burglars during the holidays, full of slapstick humor and heartwarming family lessons. Here, the Clauster family—complete with the meticulous daughter Channing, portrayed by Jones, and her clingy son-in-law Doug, played by Jason Schwartzman—embarks on a much-anticipated holiday outing. But disaster strikes in a wildly improbable mishap: Matriarch Claire gets accidentally abandoned. Enraged by this oversight, she sets off on a chaotic, rule-breaking journey to Hollywood, forcing her family to confront their flaws and realize that devoted, selfless moms deserve way more appreciation and support during the festive season. It's meant to be a mix of road-trip adventure and emotional reconciliation, but it ends up feeling like a half-baked retread.
And this is the part most people miss—the movie's flaws really pile up. The characters lack depth and feel underdeveloped, like they were sketched out hastily rather than fully fleshed into relatable people. There's a subplot involving a seemingly "perfect" Asian-American family that's not only cringe-worthy but painfully outdated, relying on stereotypes that haven't aged well since the days of early sitcoms. Plus, the film's quirky brass soundtrack—think jaunty tunes that might remind you of a marching band's oompah-pah rhythm—is leaned on way too heavily to fill in the gaps for actual humor. It's a classic sign of a comedy in trouble: when the score has to do all the heavy lifting because the jokes just aren't landing. Yet, through it all, Pfeiffer shines with her undeniable charisma, bringing warmth and strength to her role that elevates the whole thing. She absolutely deserved a script that matched her talent—maybe something more innovative, like a holiday tale that truly reimagines family dynamics without falling back on clichés.
Overall, this Christmas comedy starts strong but ends up as forgettable as melting snow. For example, imagine expecting a fresh take on holiday mishaps, only to get the same old family squabbles and contrived resolutions we've seen in countless films. It's not entirely devoid of charm, but it leaves you wishing for more originality. Perhaps that's the real controversy here: in an era where we crave diverse stories, is it fair to criticize a film for not reinventing the wheel, or should we applaud any attempt to blend genres, even if it stumbles? And Pfeiffer's performance begs the question—does star power alone make a movie worth watching, or should the material rise to meet the actor? I'd love to hear your take: Do you agree that Pfeiffer was wasted on this, or do you think the film's flaws are overstated in a saturated market? Is the Christmas genre beyond saving, or can it still surprise us? Drop your opinions in the comments—let's debate!
★★☆☆☆
12, 108min
Prime
Two-for-one cinema tickets at Everyman
Why not turn Wednesdays into your ultimate movie night? As a Times+ member, you can bring a friend along for free every Wednesday at Everyman cinemas. Enjoy the full experience with comfy plush sofas, a stocked bar, and delicious food options to make your outing even more special. Head over to mytimesplus.co.uk to learn more and book your spot!
